Customise Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorised as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyse the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customised advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyse the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

The San Jose State University Spartans women's volleyball team stands for the national anthem and player introductions during their Mountain West match against Colorado State University in Fort Collins, Colorado, on October 3, 2024. (Photo by Santiago Mejia/San Francisco Chronicle via AP)


November 26, 2024 Tags:

In a pivotal decision, U.S. Magistrate Judge S. Kato Crews ruled against a plea to bar a San Jose State women’s volleyball player from participating in the Mountain West Conference tournament due to her being transgender. The decision ensures the athlete will compete this week in Las Vegas, despite legal challenges from nine players who claimed her participation was unfair and posed safety risks.
The controversy centres on the Mountain West Conference's policy, which has allowed transgender athletes to participate since 2022. San Jose State University stood by its student-athletes, affirming their eligibility under NCAA and conference rules. In a statement, the university emphasized its commitment to inclusivity and rejected last-minute attempts to alter established policies.

The judge noted that the protesting players, who forfeited games against San Jose State, had ample time to challenge the policy earlier in the season. He dismissed their request to re-seed the tournament without the forfeited losses, citing the principle of maintaining the status quo. Since the San Jose State player has competed without issue for several seasons, her participation aligns with the established policy.

The Mountain West Conference and NCAA upheld their policies, requiring transgender athletes to meet testosterone suppression standards. This season's heightened scrutiny of the athlete’s reported identity triggered outrage among players and politicians during an election year, escalating the debate.

The controversy led several teams, including Utah State, Nevada, and Boise State, to forfeit matches rather than play against San Jose State. Some cited fairness concerns for female athletes, though Nevada's refusal to elaborate highlighted the tension surrounding the issue.

The ruling also reflects broader legal battles over transgender inclusion in sports. Plaintiffs in this case argue that Title IX, a landmark federal law prohibiting sex discrimination, excludes transgender women from women’s sports. However, courts have repeatedly ruled that discriminating based on transgender status constitutes sex-based discrimination.

Despite the backlash, San Jose State’s team prepares to compete. Their coach, Todd Kress, revealed the athletes have faced hateful messages that have impacted their morale. Still, the team aims for success in the Mountain West tournament, where the winner will secure an NCAA tournament spot.

As the debate over transgender inclusion in sports continues, this case underscores the legal and ethical complexities at play. It also highlights the growing tension between inclusivity and perceived fairness, with federal courts likely to face similar challenges in the future.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Canadian Men's Rugby Sevens Promotion Hopes Hit by Format Shake-Up

Canada’s dreams of returning to top-tier rugby sevens have been thrown off course. On the eve of the season finale....

Heartbreak in Ottawa: Senators' Season Ends in Emotional 4-2 Loss to Leafs

Brady Tkachuk fought back tears as he faced the press after Ottawa’s crushing playoff defeat. The Senators lost 4-2 to....

Golden Knights Set to Battle Oilers in Western Conference Second Round

The Vegas Golden Knights and the Edmonton Oilers are gearing up for a fierce showdown in the second round of....

Matthews Ready for Game 5 After Rest, Aiming to Finish Series

Auston Matthews, the captain of the Toronto Maple Leafs, is set to return for Game 5 of their playoff series....

Calgary Stampeders select Australian punter Masin first in CFL Global Draft

The Calgary Stampeders made a bold move in the CFL's Global Draft on Tuesday by selecting Australian punter Fraser Masin....

Tensions Soar as Hagel Exits Game 4 After Fierce Hit

The rivalry between the Tampa Bay Lightning and Florida Panthers reached another boiling point during Game 4 of their NHL....

Canada's Peterman and Gallant Fall to Italy in Tight Match

Canada's Jocelyn Peterman and Brett Gallant saw their winning streak come to an end at the World Mixed Doubles Curling....

Draisaitl’s OT Goal Lifts Oilers Over Kings, Series Now Tied

Leon Draisaitl stepped up when it mattered most, scoring on a power play late in overtime to lift the Edmonton....

Blues Defeat Jets 5-1 to Tie Playoff Series at 2-2

The St. Louis Blues came out strong on Sunday, defeating the Winnipeg Jets 5-1 to level their playoff series at....

Canadiens Thrash Capitals in Wild Game 3 at Bell Centre

The Bell Centre erupted in pure hockey madness on Friday night as the Montreal Canadiens brought down the Washington Capitals....

Edmonton Oilers Pull Off Breathtaking Comeback to Stay Alive

The Edmonton Oilers kept their playoff hopes alive with a jaw-dropping comeback against the Los Angeles Kings on Friday night.....

Benoit Becomes OT Hero as Leafs Grab 3-0 Series Lead

Simon Benoit became the unexpected star on Thursday night, scoring in overtime to give the Toronto Maple Leafs a dramatic....