On Monday, Aug 5, 2024, Judge Amit Mehta ruled that Google's ubiquitous search engine has been illegally exploiting its dominance to squash competition. (AP Photo via The Canadian Press)


August 6, 2024 Tags:

A federal judge has ruled that Google violated U.S. antitrust laws by abusing its dominance in online search and advertising. Judge Amit Mehta of the District of Columbia sided with the U.S. Justice Department and several states, declaring that Google has acted as a monopolist to maintain its market control.

The ruling, if upheld, could invalidate contracts that have long secured Google's dominant position. Google plans to appeal, asserting that while the ruling acknowledges Google offers the best search engine, it unfairly restricts their ability to make it easily accessible.

Judge Mehta found Google violated antitrust laws in the markets for general search and general search text ads, which are the ads at the top of search results. However, Google was not found liable in the search advertising market, as it does not hold a monopoly there.

This decision is a significant victory for the Justice Department and could have substantial repercussions for other tech giants like Apple, Amazon, and Meta, who are also facing similar antitrust lawsuits. The Biden administration has been actively working to curb what it perceives as anti-competitive practices across various industries, including tech.

For Google, this ruling impacts a major profit center. In 2023, its search advertising business generated over $175 billion in revenue, contributing to a total advertising revenue of $237 billion out of $307 billion in total revenue. As of mid-2023, Google controlled 91% of the global search engine market, with an even higher share on mobile platforms.

The case against Google dates back to October 2020 when the DOJ and several states filed lawsuits accusing the company of unfairly maintaining its market dominance by paying companies like Apple, Amazon, and Mozilla to make Google the default search engine on their devices and browsers. At that time, Google had a 90% share in online search.

The recent decision follows a two-month trial featuring testimonies from Google's CEO Sundar Pichai and executives from competitors like Microsoft and DuckDuckGo. The government argued that Google's contracts with device manufacturers, browser developers, and wireless carriers violated antitrust laws by making Google the default search provider, thus stifling competition.

Despite these claims, Google argued that it secured its market share through superior products, not anti-competitive practices. Microsoft's Bing holds only 3.74% of the global market, while Yahoo and DuckDuckGo have even smaller shares.

The search industry is undergoing significant changes with the introduction of generative AI responses. Google has integrated AI Overviews into its search services, offering users summarized answers. Microsoft’s Bing features a similar AI tool called Copilot. These advancements have raised concerns about the impact on website traffic and revenue, as users might get their answers directly from search results without visiting the source websites.

Google's next steps include appealing the ruling and potentially delaying the "remedies" phase of the trial until the appellate process concludes. This phase will determine how to address the anti-competitive issues identified in the ruling.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

From Truck to SUV: Slate’s shape-shifting ride is here

Slate Automotive is going back to basics—literally. Its newest model is named just Truck. That’s it. But don’t let the....

The Beer Store Confirms More Closures Across Ontario

The Beer Store is shutting down five more retail locations across Ontario. Three of these stores are in the Greater....

Hudson’s Bay Begins Final Liquidation, Historic Sale Sparks Outcry

Hudson’s Bay, Canada's oldest company, is preparing to close its remaining six stores, marking the end of an iconic era.....

Hudson’s Bay Cuts Commissions During Liquidation Sales

Hundreds of Hudson’s Bay beauty advisers are reeling after the company abruptly cut off their commission pay just weeks before....

World Economic Forum Chairman Klaus Schwab Retires After 50 Years of Global Leadership

Klaus Schwab, the 87-year-old founder of the World Economic Forum (WEF), has stepped down as chairman. After leading the influential....

China Returns $55m Boeing Jet as Trump Tariffs Impact Trade

A Boeing 737 MAX originally bound for China’s Xiamen Airlines made an unexpected return to the US on Sunday. The....

China-U.S. Tariff War Rattles Trade Ties and Businesses

Chinese exporters are on edge as a sweeping tariff war with the United States threatens long-standing trade relationships. What started....

Trump’s Commerce Chief Says, Electronics Tariff Exemption Is Temporary

The U.S. government’s decision to temporarily exempt electronics like smartphones and laptops from tariffs may not offer lasting relief. The....

Hudson’s Bay Insider Bid Protocol Raises Sale Speculation

Hudson’s Bay Company (HBC) has taken a significant step in its ongoing creditor protection process. A new internal protocol shared....

Prada to Acquire Rival Fashion House Versace in €1.25 Billion Deal

In a major move reshaping the global luxury fashion landscape, Prada Group has officially announced its acquisition of Italian fashion....

Biggest Drop in Gas Prices Across Canada: What’s Behind the Relief?

Canadians have been noticing a welcome change at the gas pumps. Over the past few weeks, fuel prices have fallen....

Trump Pauses Reciprocal Tariff for 90 Days, Hits China Harder with 125%

President Donald Trump has announced a temporary relief in his sweeping tariff policy, pausing higher levies for 90 days on....