FILE -The case centers around four voters from Guilford and Brunswick County who claim they were defamed by supporters of McCrory in the aftermath of the 2016 election. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome, File)


April 12, 2024

Attorneys representing voters accused of fraud in the 2016 election voiced concerns to the North Carolina Supreme Court about potential implications for political operatives making voter fraud allegations. The court heard arguments for Bouvier v. Porter, a case involving four voters alleging defamation by supporters of former Governor Pat McCrory after the 2016 election.

Both sides faced questioning from the justices, with uncertainty about the case's timing and implications for future elections. Plaintiffs' attorney Jeff Loperfido noted that the decision would determine the defendants' immunity regarding voter fraud claims, not whether the plaintiffs were defamed. The case stemmed from election protest petitions filed by supporters of McCrory's opponent, Governor Roy Cooper, alleging irregularities, including accusations of double voting by the plaintiffs. The case reached the state Supreme Court after an appeals court ruling in 2021 granted absolute privilege to one defendant, while others were denied. Absolute privilege shields individuals from liability in defamation cases, typically granted in judicial or legislative proceedings. 

Defense attorney Craig Schauer argued that the defendants fulfilled a role warranting absolute privilege, warning of adverse consequences if denied. Plaintiff attorney Press Millen urged the court to uphold the appellate decision, arguing against granting absolute privilege to non-participants in the election protest filing. Justices raised concerns about broadening the scope of absolute privilege and questioned the plaintiffs' arguments. Lead plaintiff Louis Bouvier expressed disappointment with the justices' questioning, emphasizing the case's significance amidst current political dynamics.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Airstrike On Gaza School Kills 27, Says Health Officials

At least 27 people died after an airstrike hit a school in Gaza City. The building, Dar al-Arqam school, was....

Survivors Found Days After Myanmar’s Deadly Earthquake

Two men have been rescued from the rubble in Myanmar, more than five days after a powerful 7.7 magnitude earthquake....

South Korea's President Yoon Removed Over Martial Law Move

South Korea’s top court removed President Yoon Suk Yeol from office on Friday. The decision came four months after he....

India Passes Controversial Bill Changing Muslim Endowment Rules Amid Opposition

India’s parliament passed a bill on Thursday that changes the rules for managing Muslim charitable endowments known as waqfs. Prime....

Gaza hit by deadly strikes as Israel pushes new military route

Israel's prime minister announced an expansion of military operations in Gaza, aiming to put more pressure on Hamas. Deadly airstrikes....

Deadly Storms And Tornadoes Threaten Millions Across The U.S.

Strong, warm winds blowing at 50 mph swept into southwestern Tennessee on Wednesday, knocking out power for thousands. This was....

Putin Orders 160,000 New Troops As Ukraine War Intensifies

Russia is launching one of its biggest military recruitment drives in years. President Vladimir Putin has signed an order to....

Trump Places Tariffs On Remote Islands Near Antarctica

A group of isolated volcanic islands near Antarctica, covered in ice and home only to penguins, is now caught in....

Israel Expands Gaza Operation To Seize Large Areas, Orders Mass Evacuations

Israel’s Defense Minister, Israel Katz, announced on Wednesday a major expansion of the military operation in Gaza. The plan includes....

Palestinian Man Tortured To Death After Criticizing Hamas, Family Says

A 22-year-old Palestinian man, Uday Rabie, was tortured and killed after publicly criticizing Hamas and joining protests against the group....

Iceland Volcano Erupts, Forcing Evacuations Near Grindavik

A powerful volcanic eruption in southwest Iceland has forced residents and tourists to evacuate. The volcano erupted early in the....

U.S. Seeks Death Penalty For Luigi Mangione In CEO’s Murder

U.S. Attorney General Pamela Bondi has ordered federal prosecutors to seek the death penalty for Luigi Mangione. He is accused....