FILE -The case centers around four voters from Guilford and Brunswick County who claim they were defamed by supporters of McCrory in the aftermath of the 2016 election. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome, File)


April 12, 2024

Attorneys representing voters accused of fraud in the 2016 election voiced concerns to the North Carolina Supreme Court about potential implications for political operatives making voter fraud allegations. The court heard arguments for Bouvier v. Porter, a case involving four voters alleging defamation by supporters of former Governor Pat McCrory after the 2016 election.

Both sides faced questioning from the justices, with uncertainty about the case's timing and implications for future elections. Plaintiffs' attorney Jeff Loperfido noted that the decision would determine the defendants' immunity regarding voter fraud claims, not whether the plaintiffs were defamed. The case stemmed from election protest petitions filed by supporters of McCrory's opponent, Governor Roy Cooper, alleging irregularities, including accusations of double voting by the plaintiffs. The case reached the state Supreme Court after an appeals court ruling in 2021 granted absolute privilege to one defendant, while others were denied. Absolute privilege shields individuals from liability in defamation cases, typically granted in judicial or legislative proceedings. 

Defense attorney Craig Schauer argued that the defendants fulfilled a role warranting absolute privilege, warning of adverse consequences if denied. Plaintiff attorney Press Millen urged the court to uphold the appellate decision, arguing against granting absolute privilege to non-participants in the election protest filing. Justices raised concerns about broadening the scope of absolute privilege and questioned the plaintiffs' arguments. Lead plaintiff Louis Bouvier expressed disappointment with the justices' questioning, emphasizing the case's significance amidst current political dynamics.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Thousands of People Bid Final Goodbye to Pope Francis at Vatican City

On Friday evening, Pope Francis' wooden coffin was sealed, officially ending the three days his body lay in state at....

George Santos Sentenced To Seven Years For Fraud In House Campaign

George Santos, a former US representative, received a seven-year prison sentence on Friday. The case ended a long controversy that....

Virginia Giuffre, Epstein Accuser, Dies at 41 in Australia

Virginia Giuffre, known for accusing Prince Andrew and Jeffrey Epstein of sexual abuse, has died by suicide at 41. Her....

Pakistan halts Indian visas After Deadly Kashmir Attack On Tourists

Pakistan has taken strong steps against India following a deadly militant attack in Indian-administered Kashmir that killed 26 tourists. The....

China Opens Moon Rocks To Global Scientists, Including the US

China has agreed to let scientists from six countries, including the United States, study Moon rocks it collected during its....

Israel Admits Killing UN Worker In Gaza After Initial Denial

Israel's military has admitted that its troops killed a United Nations (UN) worker in the Gaza Strip last month, after....

Trump Criticizes Putin Over Deadly Russian Strikes On Kyiv

US President Donald Trump has expressed his anger over the deadly Russian missile strikes on Kyiv, Ukraine, stating that he....

Thousands Gather To Bid Farewell To Pope Francis In Vatican

Pope Francis’ body was laid in state at St. Peter’s Basilica on Wednesday, allowing thousands of Catholic pilgrims to pay....

India Calls In Pakistan Envoy Over Kashmir Attack That Killed 26

India took strong diplomatic steps against Pakistan after a deadly attack in Kashmir. The government summoned Pakistan’s top diplomat in....

India Halts Indus Treaty, Closes Attari Border Over Militant Attack

India has taken strong action against Pakistan following a deadly terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir’s Pahalgam. This attack killed....

6.2 Magnitude Earthquake Hits Near Istanbul, Causes Panic

A strong 6.2-magnitude earthquake hit off the coast of Istanbul on Wednesday, causing panic in the Turkish city. The quake....

Gaza Health Ministry Defends Accuracy Of Death Toll Data

At al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, Alam Hirzallah faces a heartbreaking task: registering the deaths of his cousin’s wife and....