Photo by Negative Space from pexels.com


July 1, 2024 Tags:

Canadian creators and publishers are pressing the government to address the unauthorized use of their content in training generative artificial intelligence systems. They argue that this practice infringes on copyright and undermines their ability to control how their work is used. On the other hand, AI companies contend that such use is essential for advancing AI technology in Canada and should not be restricted.

These opposing viewpoints are being presented in submissions to a consultation on copyright and AI by the federal government. The consultation aims to update Canada’s copyright laws to accommodate emerging technologies like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, which can generate text, images, videos, and code based on extensive datasets it has learned from.

Access Copyright, representing writers, artists, and publishers, describes the current use of their works by AI systems as occurring in a "black box." They highlight that while rightsholders are aware of this activity, they lack the means to identify which works are being used or to prevent unauthorized use.

Music Canada, representing major record labels, pointed out a specific incident where an AI-generated song mimicked popular artists without permission, illustrating the extent to which proprietary data is being ingested without authorization.

The Writers’ Guild of Canada has called for basic disclosure and reporting obligations, emphasizing the disparity in information between developers, who have detailed knowledge of how content is utilized, and creators, who are often left uninformed.

While some organizations have reached licensing agreements with AI companies, the Canadian Authors Association argues that many rightsholders face significant challenges in licensing their content due to lack of transparency about its use.

Legal actions in the United States highlight these transparency issues, with cases where AI companies argue that rightsholders cannot prove infringement without specific details about the training data used.

The Canadian Media Producers Association stresses the urgency of addressing these issues, urging the government to implement transparency requirements to protect rightsholders.

AI companies, however, argue that the level of transparency demanded by rightsholders is impractical. Microsoft, for example, asserts that recording and disclosing vast amounts of training data would hinder AI development.

Google echoes this sentiment, stating that AI training is already exempt from copyright law and that additional regulations could impede innovation by exposing sensitive competitive information.

Cohere, a Canadian AI firm, likens using content for AI training to reading books for knowledge acquisition, asserting that it does not constitute copyright infringement and should be clarified as such in the law.

The Council of Canadian Innovators warns that stringent disclosure rules could disproportionately harm smaller tech companies compared to larger competitors, potentially stifling their growth and innovation.

As Canada navigates these complex issues at the intersection of AI and copyright law, the outcome of the consultation will likely shape the future landscape for both creators seeking protection and AI companies aiming to innovate.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Trump Weighs Tariffs to Fight Digital Taxes on US Tech Firms

Former President Donald Trump is considering imposing tariffs on countries that tax American tech giants like Alphabet (Google) and Meta....

Elon Musk’s $44B Gamble on X May Finally Pay Off

When Elon Musk purchased Twitter in October 2022 for $44 billion, many saw it as a costly mistake. He immediately....

NASA Leadership Shake-Up Raises Doubts on Moon Mission Plans

NASA is facing a leadership shake-up as four senior officials linked to its Artemis moon program step down, raising concerns....

Elon Musk Unveils Grok 3, Claims It Outperforms ChatGPT & More

Elon Musk’s AI startup, xAI, has officially launched Grok 3, its latest artificial intelligence model, which he claims surpasses leading....

Google Canada Rejects Claims of Market Power Abuse

Google Canada has dismissed allegations of monopolistic practices in response to the Competition Bureau’s lawsuit over its advertising operations. The....

Google Expands AI Hub in Poland for Energy, Cybersecurity

Google is strengthening its presence in Poland by expanding its artificial intelligence (AI) initiatives in key sectors like energy and....

OpenAI Rejects Musk’s $97.4B Bid to Take Over the Company

OpenAI’s board has firmly declined a $97.4 billion buyout offer led by Elon Musk, reinforcing its stance that the company....

TikTok Returns to U.S. App Stores After Temporary Ban

Google and Apple have reinstated TikTok on their U.S. app stores following a brief removal, marking another twist in the....

NASA’s Stuck Astronauts Set to Return to Earth Sooner

Two NASA astronauts stranded aboard the International Space Station (ISS) for over eight months may finally return home sooner than....

Beats Powerbeats Pro 2 Launches with Heart-Rate Monitor

Apple’s Beats brand has unveiled the Powerbeats Pro 2, a long-awaited update to its popular fitness-focused earbuds. This new version....

Space Telescope Captures Stunning Ring of Light Around Galaxy

A newly spotted glowing ring in deep space has captivated astronomers worldwide. The Euclid space telescope, launched by the European....

Musk’s $97.4B Bid for OpenAI Sparks Fresh AI Battle

Elon Musk and his group have made a staggering $97.4 billion offer to take over OpenAI, reigniting tensions with CEO....