Aylo, the company behind adult websites like Pornhub, faces condemnation for sharing intimate images without proper consent, leading to severe impacts on victims. (IT World Canada)


March 01, 2024

A Canadian federal privacy commissioner has found that Aylo, the company behind popular adult websites like Pornhub, violated privacy laws by allowing intimate images to be shared without the direct consent of those depicted. This ruling comes after an investigation initiated in 2020 when a woman discovered that her ex-boyfriend had uploaded an intimate video and other images of her to Aylo websites without her consent.

The investigation revealed that Aylo, formerly known as MindGeek, did not seek the complainant's consent to collect, use, and disclose her intimate images. Instead, the company relied solely on her ex-boyfriend's assertion that she had consented to the distribution of the video on Aylo's websites. This failure to obtain proper consent was a violation of the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA).

The report made several recommendations to Aylo to improve its content handling processes, but the company has not committed to implementing any of them. Despite changes to its consent practices in recent years, Aylo has not provided evidence that it is obtaining meaningful consent directly from everyone appearing in images and videos posted on its websites.

The report highlighted the severe impacts on victims of non-consensual disclosure of intimate images, including social stigmatization, psychological damage, financial loss, and even attempted suicide. The complainant in this case had to hire a professional takedown service to remove over 700 instances of her intimate images from more than 80 websites. Despite these efforts, the material continued to resurface online.

Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne emphasized the need for stronger laws to address online harms. The proposed Online Harms Act would empower a Digital Safety Commission to order the removal of such images from designated websites within 24 hours or face significant penalties. Additionally, the ongoing debate over the Consumer Privacy Protection Act (CPPA) could grant the OPC broader powers to enforce compliance.

Under the CPPA, Dufresne would have the authority to order Aylo to immediately delete content where individuals in uploaded images or videos have not given express consent. However, under the current law, the OPC can only make recommendations. Dufresne has the option to ask the Federal Court to compel Aylo to comply with the recommendations.

The commission's recommendations include stopping the upload of intimate content without obtaining meaningful consent, deleting previously collected content without consent, implementing a privacy management program, and agreeing to oversight by an independent third party for five years.

Dufresne hopes that Aylo will reconsider its silence on the recommendations and take quick action. He also urged other social media sites to take note of the report's principles on obtaining consent for posting sensitive material.

The case underscores the need for stronger privacy protections and enforcement measures to prevent and remedy privacy violations, especially concerning the non-consensual sharing of intimate images or videos. Despite Aylo's claims of providing safe platforms, the investigation revealed a concerning lack of privacy protections and a failure to obtain proper consent.

The report concluded that Aylo's consent model, which relied on the uploader's attestation of consent, did not constitute reasonable efforts to ensure meaningful consent. Despite changes to its uploading policy, Aylo's platforms continue to face challenges in preventing unwanted content from returning.

In light of these findings, the OPC recommends stronger laws and enforcement mechanisms to protect individuals' privacy and dignity.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Bitcoin Investor Buys an Entire SpaceX Flight for the Ultimate Polar Adventure

A bold new chapter in space tourism unfolded as Chun Wang, a Bitcoin investor and entrepreneur, launched into orbit on....

Elon Musk’s xAI Acquires X in $33 Billion Stock Deal

Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence startup, xAI, has officially taken over his social media platform, X, in a deal valued at....

Trump Considers Lowering Tariffs to Seal TikTok Deal

Former U.S. President Donald Trump signalled on Wednesday that he might reduce tariffs on China to facilitate the sale of....

U.S. Robotics Firms Urge National Strategy to Compete China

American robotics companies are calling for a national U.S. robotics strategy to strengthen the industry and maintain a competitive edge....

Waymo Plans Self-Driving Taxi Service in Washington by 2026

Alphabet’s autonomous taxi service, Waymo, is expanding to Washington, D.C., with plans to launch in 2026. The announcement, made on....

Trump Aides Used Signal for Secret War Talks – What to Know

Top officials from the Trump administration reportedly used the encrypted messaging app Signal to discuss military plans, sparking concerns over....

PsiQuantum Secures $750M to Advance Quantum Computing

According to sources, Quantum computing startup PsiQuantum is securing at least $750 million in funding, pushing its valuation to $6....

Are We Ready to Mine Metals from Space? The Future of Asteroid Mining

Asteroid Mining: A Sci-Fi Dream or an Inevitable Future? For decades, space enthusiasts and scientists have imagined a future where....

Nvidia CEO Surprised By Public Quantum Computing Companies

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang admitted he was unaware that publicly traded quantum computing firms existed when he previously commented on....

Tesla Faces Crisis: Cybertruck Recall & Musk’s Trump Ties

Tesla and its CEO Elon Musk are in hot water as controversy swirls around the company. One of Tesla’s strongest....

Humanoid Robots Could Arrive Sooner Than Expected, Says Nvidia CEO

The world may be closer to a robotics revolution than most people think. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang believes humanoid robots....

Nvidia’s AI Vision: Jensen Huang Unveils Future at GTC 2025

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang took center stage at the GTC 2025 conference, often dubbed “AI Woodstock,” to discuss the rapid....