FILE PHOTO: Jury Begins Deliberation in Legal Battle Between Arm and Qualcomm After Final Arguments


December 21, 2024 Tags:

In a recent legal clash between tech giants Qualcomm and Arm Holdings, a U.S. federal court jury ruled in Qualcomm's favour on a pivotal licensing matter, though the trial ended with mixed outcomes. The decision removes some uncertainty surrounding Qualcomm’s ambitious push into the laptop chip market but leaves room for future legal disputes.
The trial, held in Delaware, centred on Qualcomm’s acquisition of Nuvia, a startup specializing in custom chip designs, for $1.4 billion in 2021. The main point of contention was whether Nuvia violated its licensing agreement with Arm, a claim Arm sought to address by demanding the destruction of Nuvia’s custom chip designs. After nine hours of deliberation over two days, the jury could not agree on this issue, resulting in a mistrial.

However, the jury unanimously determined that Qualcomm’s chips, developed using Nuvia technology, are properly licensed under Qualcomm’s agreement with Arm. This ruling allows Qualcomm to continue selling these chips, a cornerstone of its expansion into the personal computer market. The company aims to introduce advanced processors tailored for artificial intelligence (AI) tasks like chatbots and image generation, an area where competitors like Nvidia, AMD, and MediaTek are also venturing with Arm-based technology.

Qualcomm celebrated the verdict, stating it validated its right to innovate and protected its chip designs under its existing contract with Arm. Arm, on the other hand, expressed disappointment over the jury's inability to reach consensus on its claims and vowed to seek a retrial.

The trial highlighted broader industry implications, particularly regarding Arm's licensing model. Arm provides firms with access to its computing architecture while also selling ready-made core designs. Companies like Qualcomm, Apple, and Nuvia license Arm’s architecture but develop custom cores, blurring the boundaries of intellectual property ownership.

Judge Maryellen Noreika, who presided over the case, urged the parties to mediate rather than resort to another trial. “Neither side would have had a clear victory,” she remarked, reflecting the complex nature of the case.

The legal wrangling also revealed concerns about royalty rates. Before being acquired by Qualcomm, Nuvia was paying higher royalty fees for Arm’s technology. Qualcomm integrated Nuvia's designs into its own products, which operate under lower royalty rates, sparking Arm’s objections.

Analysts noted the trial’s outcome alleviates immediate risks for Qualcomm’s road map, especially regarding its use of Nuvia’s cores. However, Arm’s future plans seem unaffected, as its growth projections do not hinge on extracting higher royalties from Qualcomm.

Industry experts emphasize the trial’s broader impact. Arm’s licensing agreements form the foundation of technologies ranging from electric toothbrushes to satellites, and any shifts in these agreements could ripple across the tech world. For now, the verdict underscores the ongoing battle over innovation, intellectual property, and market dominance in the rapidly evolving semiconductor industry.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

EV Interest Dips Among Canadians for Third Year Straight

A recent AutoTrader survey reveals that interest in electric vehicles (EVs) among Canadians is steadily declining, despite a noticeable drop....

Nations Boost Digital Defences as Cyber Threats Grow

In a troubling sign of the times, hackers backed by Russia’s government infiltrated a water facility in the small Texas....

Google to Challenge Part of US Court's Ruling in Monopoly Case

Google, part of Alphabet Inc., has announced plans to appeal a portion of the recent court ruling in the ongoing....

Google Faces £5B UK Lawsuit Over Search Engine Control

Google is now facing a massive £5 billion lawsuit in the United Kingdom, accusing the tech giant of using its....

Meta CEO Zuckerberg eyed Instagram split in 2018, email reveals

According to an internal email revealed during an ongoing antitrust trial, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg considered splitting Instagram from Facebook....

Meta’s Monopoly Trial Begins: What’s at Stake for Instagram and WhatsApp

In a major legal showdown, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg appeared in court on Monday as part of a historic antitrust....

 Future Legislation Must Address AI’s Role in News Compensation

As the media landscape evolves, researchers in Canada suggest future laws aimed at balancing the power between tech giants and....

Ireland Investigates Musk’s X Over AI Data Collection Practices

Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC) has launched a formal investigation into Elon Musk’s platform X, formerly known as Twitter, over....

Google Cuts Prices for U.S. Government to Compete with Microsoft

In a bold move to expand its presence in the public sector, Google is now offering deep discounts on its....

Alphabet Sticks to $75B Spending Plan Amid Tariff Concerns

Alphabet, the parent company of Google, has confirmed its decision to invest a staggering $75 billion in 2025, mainly to....

TSMC Faces Over $1B Fine Over Huawei Chip Link: US Probe

Taiwan’s leading chipmaker, TSMC, may be hit with a fine of over $1 billion after a U.S. investigation revealed one....

Shopify CEO: AI Skills Now a Must for All Employees

Shopify is taking artificial intelligence more seriously than ever before. In a recent internal memo, CEO Tobi Lütke told employees....