The Apple iPhone 16 Pro and 16 Pro Max were showcased at an Apple Store in London on September 20. (Peter Nicholls/Getty Images via CNN)


December 20, 2024 Tags:

Apple’s AI summarizer feature, which aims to condense news into digestible headlines, has sparked controversy after generating false information. Reporters Without Borders (RSF), a global press freedom organization, has called for the feature’s removal, citing risks to media credibility and public trust.
The incident came to light when Apple’s AI tool incorrectly summarized a BBC report, sending users a notification claiming that Luigi Mangione, a suspect in a high-profile murder case, had died by suicide. In reality, this detail was not part of the BBC’s reporting. The BBC expressed concerns to Apple and demanded action, but the tech giant has yet to respond.

Vincent Berthier, head of RSF's technology and journalism desk, criticized the tool, stating, “AI systems operate on probabilities, not facts. Such errors harm media credibility and misinform the public.” RSF warned that the immature state of AI makes it unreliable for generating accurate news summaries and urged Apple to act responsibly.

The tool, introduced in June, allows users to receive condensed news summaries in various formats, such as paragraphs or bullet points. However, its limitations have been evident since its public rollout in October. In another mishap, the AI summarizer inaccurately reported that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had been arrested. In reality, the news concerned an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court, but the notification oversimplified this, leading to widespread confusion.

Critics argue that the AI summaries present significant risks to both media outlets and public trust. The summaries are generated under the media publisher's banner, which could lead audiences to wrongly attribute inaccuracies to the news outlet itself. This jeopardizes both the outlet’s reputation and the integrity of journalism.

AI tools have been a contentious topic in the news industry. While some outlets cautiously integrate AI for content creation, others fear the implications of tools like Apple’s, which operate independently of editorial oversight. The issue is compounded by allegations that many AI systems are trained on copyrighted materials without permission. Major news organizations, including The New York Times, have taken legal action, while others, like Axel Springer, have opted for licensing deals with AI developers.

RSF emphasized the broader dangers posed by premature AI adoption, highlighting the need for stringent safeguards before deploying such tools. Meanwhile, the BBC reaffirmed its commitment to providing trustworthy information and urged Apple to address the flaws in its AI system.

Apple has yet to release an official statement regarding the controversy, leaving questions about the future of its AI summarizer unresolved. The situation underscores the growing tension between technological innovation and ethical journalism, as media outlets navigate the challenges of AI integration.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Samsung Drops Ultra-Slim S25 Edge as Apple Readies iPhone 17 Air

In a surprise move, Samsung has launched a new, sleeker version of its popular S25 smartphone—called the Galaxy S25 Edge.....

Texas Secures $1.4B Settlement From Google In Major Privacy Lawsuit

In a landmark legal victory, Texas has reached a $1.4 billion settlement with Google over claims the tech company secretly....

Nvidia Tones Down H20 Chip for China to Work Around US Ban

Nvidia is planning to release a toned-down version of its H20 artificial intelligence chip to Chinese customers, aiming for a....

Google Stocks Tumble After Apple Testimony Sparks AI Worries

In a major blow to tech giant Google, its parent company Alphabet saw its stock value plummet by more than....

US Moves to blow up Google with proposed teardown of its Digital Ads

The U.S. government is stepping up its fight against Google, aiming to break apart the company’s powerful digital advertising business.....

OpenAI Drops For-Profit Plans, Keeps Nonprofit in Control

OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, has decided not to shift to a fully for-profit model after months of debate and....

New Clue to Cosmic Gold Found in Magnetar Starquakes

A recent discovery may have brought scientists one step closer to solving a long-standing mystery: where does gold come from....

Meta Launches Personal AI App to Rival Chatgpt

Meta has stepped into the AI spotlight with the launch of its first standalone artificial intelligence app, designed to compete....

Amazon's First Internet Satellites Head to Space to Join Global Race

Amazon has officially entered the race for space-based internet. On Monday, it launched its first group of internet satellites into....

Alphabet climbs as AI bets drive ad strength, quelling market fears

Alphabet, the parent company of Google, saw its shares rise nearly 4% on Friday after it posted strong quarterly results.....

EV Interest Dips Among Canadians for Third Year Straight

A recent AutoTrader survey reveals that interest in electric vehicles (EVs) among Canadians is steadily declining, despite a noticeable drop....

Nations Boost Digital Defences as Cyber Threats Grow

In a troubling sign of the times, hackers backed by Russia’s government infiltrated a water facility in the small Texas....