Higgs has not ruled out using the notwithstanding clause to force through legislation that would allow authorities to put people with drug addiction into treatment against their will. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Stephen MacGillivray


April 04, 2024

New Brunswick's Premier Blaine Higgs has stated that he hasn't ruled out the possibility of using a constitutional provision known as the notwithstanding clause to implement legislation that would authorize authorities to compel certain individuals into drug treatment programs.

During a press briefing on Tuesday, Higgs revealed that the proposed legislation, titled the Compassionate Intervention Act, is not yet finalized for presentation. However, he emphasized that the option of utilizing the notwithstanding clause, which shields bills from legal challenges related to violations of Charter rights, remains on the table. He suggested that further discussions and deliberations are necessary once the bill is introduced in May, postponing its tabling, initially slated for the current week.

The Compassionate Intervention Act aims to facilitate the placement of individuals suffering from severe drug addiction into treatment programs following consultations with their families, medical professionals, and law enforcement officials. Public Safety Minister Kris Austin elaborated on the rationale behind the bill, highlighting the objective of helping individuals who are deeply entrenched in addiction to reclaim sobriety through medical intervention. Austin emphasized that the intent is not to indiscriminately coerce individuals into treatment but rather to intervene on behalf of those whose addiction has significantly impaired their ability to make informed choices about their health and well-being.

However, concerns have been raised regarding the potential violation of Charter rights if individuals are forcibly placed into treatment programs. Wayne MacKay, a legal expert from Dalhousie University, expressed apprehension about the prospect of compelling individuals into treatment against their will, citing it as a clear infringement on their freedom and right to autonomy. He further noted that targeting individuals with drug addiction may raise issues related to equality rights, as it singles out a specific group based on their disability.

Andrew McDougall, a political science professor at the University of Toronto, shed light on the notwithstanding clause's function within the Canadian legal framework. He explained that governments may invoke this clause preemptively to shield legislation from potential Charter challenges, particularly when there are concerns about the legislation's compliance with Charter rights. McDougall referenced previous instances where provinces like Quebec and Saskatchewan had employed the notwithstanding clause to safeguard contentious legislation, albeit acknowledging that its utilization is considered an extraordinary measure due to its implications.

Despite potential legal challenges, MacKay emphasized that the courts have limited authority to block the use of the notwithstanding clause based solely on perceived undesirability. He underscored that political accountability for its utilization lies primarily with the electorate, with the clause subject to renewal every five years.

In summary, the possibility of employing the notwithstanding clause to enact legislation compelling individuals into drug treatment programs has sparked debate and raised questions about its compatibility with Charter rights and principles of individual autonomy. While proponents argue for the necessity of such measures in addressing severe cases of addiction, critics caution against potential infringements on fundamental rights and freedoms. The ultimate decision on the use of the notwithstanding clause and the adoption of the Compassionate Intervention Act rests with the government, pending further discussions and considerations.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Kennedy’s HHS Overhaul Puts Addiction Treatment At Risk

A major shakeup in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) could lead to the weakening—or even elimination—of....

Deadly Fungal Superbug Candida Auris Spreads Rapidly in Hospitals

A dangerous fungal superbug, Candida auris (C. auris), is rapidly spreading in hospitals and nursing homes, raising serious public health....

Researchers in Limbo as Columbia Caves to Trump’s Demands for $400M

Columbia University is facing intense scrutiny after agreeing to strict policy changes to regain $400 million in federal funding revoked....

U.S. Cuts LGBTQ Health Research Funding, Sparking Outrage

The Trump administration has abruptly canceled dozens of federal grants supporting research on LGBTQ health, drawing criticism from scientists and....

Canada Expands Dental Care Plan Ahead of Expected Election

Millions of uninsured Canadians will soon have access to affordable dental care as the federal government expands its Canadian Dental....

Diffabilities YEG Fights Stigma On World Down Syndrome Day

An Edmonton-based organization, Diffabilities YEG, hosted a special event on Friday to mark World Down Syndrome Day. The event aimed....

Bella Ramsey Opens Up About Autism Diagnosis: "It Was Liberating"

Bella Ramsey, known for their Emmy-nominated role in The Last of Us, recently revealed their autism diagnosis. In an interview....

Measles Cases Double in Alberta as Vaccination Rates Decline

Measles, once considered eradicated in Canada, is making a troubling comeback in Alberta. The number of confirmed cases has nearly....

Slushy Drinks Could Make Kids Sick—Experts Warn!

Researchers have warned that children under the age of 8 should avoid slushy ice drinks containing glycerol. This comes after....

Alberta Government Lawyers Defend Youth Gender-Affirming Care Ban In Court

Alberta's controversial transgender law returned to court on Tuesday, with government lawyers defending it as a science-based measure designed to....

Utah Becomes First U.S. State to Ban Fluoride in Public Water

Utah is making history by becoming the first state to ban fluoride in public drinking water. Despite opposition from dentists....

Butter Lovers, Beware! New Study Links Butter Intake to Shorter Lifespan

Butter is a kitchen staple, loved for its creamy richness. But could your daily dollop be shortening your life? A....