The federal government tabled the 2024 budget on Tuesday, which relies on revenue from an increase to the capital gains inclusion rate. (Jean-François Benoit/CBC)


April 20, 2024

A wave of criticism from Canadian entrepreneurs and investors is directed at the federal government's budget for its move to expand taxes on the wealthy, igniting concerns about a potential brain drain and exacerbating Canada's existing productivity challenges.

In the recently unveiled 2024 budget, Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland announced plans to raise the inclusion rate of the capital gains tax from 50 percent to 67 percent for businesses and trusts, with expectations of generating around $19 billion in additional revenue.

Capital gains refer to the profits earned by individuals or businesses from selling assets like stocks or second homes. Under the new changes, individuals would face increased taxes on profits exceeding $250,000.

The government estimates that approximately 40,000 individuals (or 0.13 percent of Canadians annually) and 307,000 companies across Canada will be affected by these changes.

However, members of the business community argue that broadening the taxable amount will significantly harm productivity, investment, and entrepreneurship in Canada, potentially prompting talented individuals and startups to relocate elsewhere.

Benjamin Bergen, President of the Council of Canadian Innovators (CCI), highlighted the disproportionate focus on the capital gains tax within the budget, overshadowing other aspects that could have garnered excitement from the business community.

The CCI has initiated an open letter, signed by over 1,000 individuals in the Canadian business sector, urging the government to reconsider the tax adjustment.

Among those expressing concerns are Shopify CEO Tobi Lütke and president Harley Finkelstein, who emphasized their apprehensions about the proposed tax hike.

Former Finance Minister Bill Morneau criticized the budget, suggesting that it discourages business investments in Canada's innovation sector, posing potential challenges for investors.

Canada's longstanding productivity issues, as indicated by Bank of Canada senior deputy governor Carolyn Rogers, have reached critical levels, necessitating urgent measures to address them, particularly following a period of economic downturn.

While the government argues that the tax changes aim to enhance affordability for younger generations and fund housing initiatives, critics fear adverse effects on productivity growth and investment.

The revised tax policy could deter investors and founders from engaging with Canadian companies, exacerbating existing challenges in accessing funding within a high-interest rate environment.

Despite concerns raised by various stakeholders, Associate Economics Professor Lindsay Tedds suggests that the impact of the tax change on Canada's talent pool might be overstated, emphasizing that grassroots entrepreneurs' decisions are not heavily influenced by tax rates.

However, others argue that the government's approach appears contradictory, offering tailored tax breaks while simultaneously introducing measures perceived as dampening investment and innovation.

Leaders within Canadian industries, such as Dennis Darby of Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters, express disappointment with the tax adjustment, advocating for alternative proposals to incentivize business retention and enhance competitiveness.

Toronto tech entrepreneur Ali Asaria, subject to the expanded capital gains inclusion rate, acknowledges the impact on the wealthy but views it as a fair adjustment. He stresses the need for broader policy reforms to address critical issues like housing affordability to foster an environment conducive to investment and business growth.

Overall, the debate surrounding the budget's tax changes reflects broader concerns about Canada's economic competitiveness and the government's approach to fostering innovation and investment.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

Markets Brace for Turbulence and Recession Fears as Liberation Day Approaches

Investors are on edge as Liberation Day, set for April 2, nears. As the year's first quarter ends on a....

Tencent Invests €1.2B in Ubisoft Spin-Off to Expand Gaming Empire

Chinese tech giant Tencent has made a €1.2 billion ($1.25 billion) investment in a newly formed Ubisoft subsidiary, securing a....

Trump’s Auto Tariffs Hit Canada Hard: A Trade War Unfolds

The U.S. has imposed a 25% tariff on finished vehicles imported into the country, marking one of the most severe....

Quebec Budget 2025 -2026 Fights Trump Tariffs But Sinks Deeper Into Debt

Quebec's finance minister, Eric Girard, has unveiled a historic $165.8-billion budget, aiming to strengthen the province’s economy in response to....

Samsung TV Pioneer Han Jong-Hee Passed Away at 63

Samsung Electronics has lost one of its key leaders. Han Jong-Hee, the co-CEO who played a major role in shaping....

Trump Plans New Tariffs for Vehicles & Pharmaceuticals, Near Future

U.S. President Donald Trump has announced plans to impose tariffs on vehicles and pharmaceuticals, further expanding his aggressive trade policies.....

Key Business Events to Watch in Canada This Week

This week brings several major developments in the Canadian business world. From political campaigns to economic reports, here are the....

Hudson’s Bay Begins Liquidation, But Six Stores Are Spared

Hudson’s Bay, Canada’s oldest company, has received court approval to start liquidating most of its stores. The Ontario Superior Court....

U.S. Tariffs Could be an Uphill Battle for Canada’s Greenhouse Industry

A fresh wave of U.S. tariffs on Canadian imports has sent shockwaves through Canada’s greenhouse sector, which heavily depends on....

Google’s $32B Wiz Deal: A Game-Changer for Cloud Security

Google has announced its biggest-ever acquisition, agreeing to buy cybersecurity firm Wiz for $32 billion in cash. This massive deal....

PepsiCo To Acquire Poppi to Expand in Healthy Soda Market

PepsiCo announced on Monday that it will acquire the prebiotic soda brand Poppi for $1.95 billion. The move comes as....

Hudson’s Bay May Start Its Stores Liquidation As Early As Tuesday

Toronto – Hudson’s Bay, the retail giant, is battling for survival as it seeks court approval to begin liquidating its....