Temple University doctoral student Jaggar DeMarco, with chronic respiratory failure, expresses frustration over insurance and bureaucracy, seen here in Philadelphia on March 6, 2024, utilizing a battery-powered ventilator. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke)


March 11, 2024

Grace Armant, an 84-year-old woman afflicted with Lou Gehrig’s disease, communicates through a device due to her loss of speech. She asserts that UnitedHealthcare has repeatedly denied her doctor's requests for coverage of a vital breathing apparatus, essential for her condition. Armant's struggle reflects a broader issue affecting patients across the U.S. who require specialized home ventilators as their lung function declines.

Physicians nationwide report increasing obstacles in obtaining coverage for home ventilators from insurers like UnitedHealthcare. Patients often confront hurdles, such as experimenting with less effective alternatives before insurers authorize coverage for the necessary device. Furthermore, insurers sometimes refuse coverage for a second machine needed for mobility transitions, complicating patients' lives.

The surge in prescribed ventilators has drawn scrutiny from insurers. Medicare spending on ventilators skyrocketed from $3 million to nearly $269 million between 2009 and 2017, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General. As a result, insurers have tightened their criteria for coverage.

These home ventilators, known as "noninvasive" ventilators, aid continuous breathing by delivering air into the lungs, primarily through a mask. They are distinct from hospital ventilators that necessitate tracheal surgery. Despite their importance, insurance rejections for these devices have surged, particularly for patients with Lou Gehrig’s disease or advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

UnitedHealthcare maintains that it covers ventilators based on various factors, including the patient's condition and health plan terms. However, physicians criticize the insurer's stringent guidelines, noting that even severely ill patients face coverage denials.

Patients and their families endure protracted battles to secure coverage. Dale Harper's struggle to obtain a ventilator for his son Jacob, afflicted with a severe form of ALS, exemplifies this challenge. Similarly, Grace Armant's family has encountered significant hurdles in securing ventilator coverage, prompting consideration of hospice care, despite its limitations.

Ventilator coverage issues extend beyond UnitedHealthcare to other insurers like Aetna. Patients like Jaggar DeMarco face multiple denials before securing essential equipment, often through employer intervention.

The need for a second ventilator for daytime wheelchair use complicates matters further. Insurers often reject coverage for this necessity, leaving patients vulnerable to errors in machine adjustment when transitioning between bed and wheelchair.

Insurers attribute coverage denials to evolving technology, increased ventilator usage, and expanded patient populations. This trend, observed by medical professionals, underscores insurers' reaction to the changing landscape of ventilator use.

For ALS patients lacking ventilator access, limited alternatives exist, including less effective devices, hospice care, or invasive procedures like tracheostomies. Without adequate coverage, patients risk frequent hospitalizations or premature death due to respiratory failure.

The plight of patients like Grace Armant and Jaggar DeMarco underscores the critical need for insurance reforms to ensure timely access to life-sustaining equipment, without which patients face severe health risks and diminished quality of life.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

You may also like

RSV Protection for Infants is Limited to a Few Provinces in Canada

This year, Canada is facing a concerning rise in Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) infections, particularly among babies under one-year-old. As....

Intestinal Infection Outbreak Declared in Toronto’s Underhoused Community

Toronto is grappling with an outbreak of Shigellosis, a highly contagious and drug-resistant bacterial illness, that has primarily affected the....

Nutrition Experts Recommend More Beans, Less Red Meat in US Diet

A fresh set of recommendations from a panel of nutrition experts aims to transform the American diet, urging people to....

Morocco Creates Africa's First Mpox Test, Reducing Imports

TAMESNA, Morocco (AP) — During the COVID-19 pandemic, African countries faced difficulties in obtaining crucial testing kits, prompting officials to....

USDA Orders nationwide milk testing to track bird flu spread

The U.S. government has announced a new initiative to test the nation's milk supply for bird flu, aiming to monitor....

Edmonton Zoo Elephant Lucy Gets Medical Ok As She Approaches 50th Birthday

EDMONTON — Lucy, the renowned elephant at the Edmonton Valley Zoo, is in good health as she approaches her 50th....

Why Are Food Recalls in Canada Happening So Often?

Canada has witnessed numerous significant food recalls this year, from salad kits to plant-based milks, with some leading to serious....

Canadian Experts Weigh In On Fluoridating Drinking Water

For decades, adding fluoride to drinking water has been a key strategy in improving dental health across North America. Experts....

Supreme Court To Hear Transgender Rights Case On Minor Treatment Ban

The U.S. Supreme Court is considering a significant case on transgender rights, hearing arguments this Wednesday regarding a Tennessee law....

Study: Belly Fat Linked To Alzheimer's Signs 20 Years Early

A new study has revealed that changes in brain health linked to obesity can start much earlier than expected —....

AI in Pharma! Insitro CEO on How ML Can Improve Drugs

WASHINGTON (AP) — While artificial intelligence (AI) is already revolutionizing sectors like programming and customer service, the pharmaceutical industry is....

2 Shots a Year Could End AIDS—But Will Everyone Get It?

A new drug has been hailed as a potential breakthrough in the fight against AIDS, with some experts calling it....