Steven MacKinnon has stood up for the planned high-speed rail project linking Toronto and Quebec City, responding to criticism from Conservatives and other opponents. CTV
Government House Leader Steven MacKinnon has spoken out against calls to cancel a proposed high-speed rail line linking Toronto and Quebec City, as debate over the project continues.
Government Stands Firm on Rail Plan
The federal government plans to move ahead with the multi-billion-dollar rail project, with construction expected to begin near the end of the decade. The Crown corporation Alto will oversee the development.
MacKinnon defended the plan during a recent interview, responding directly to criticism from Pierre Poilievre, who labelled the project a “boondoggle” and a “waste of money.”
“In terms of the Conservatives, they used to think big,” MacKinnon said.
Drawing on Canada’s Past Vision
MacKinnon pointed to earlier Conservative leaders who supported major infrastructure projects.
“You know, (former prime minister) Brian Mulroney used to think big,” he said. “Heavens. (Former prime minister) John A. Macdonald used to think in terms of building an intercontinental railroad.”
He also noted that Conservative members backed high-speed rail during their 2023 convention, suggesting that support for such projects existed within the party.
Concerns From Communities
Criticism has not come only from Conservatives. Some concerns have also emerged from the Bloc Québécois and from rural communities located along the proposed route.
People in these areas have raised questions about consultation and how the rail line may affect their communities.
MacKinnon said the government would take a practical approach when choosing the route. He stressed that officials would rely on “common sense” as they move forward.
Economic Impact Highlighted
MacKinnon described the project as a major step forward for the country’s economy. He said many Canadians have long viewed high-speed rail as an idea worth pursuing.
“Growing up, this was a dream, high-speed rail,” he said. “What we’re saying to Canadians now is it can be real.”
He added that the project could bring wide economic benefits and improve transportation between major cities.
Questions Remain About Costs
Despite the strong defence, some key details remain unclear. When asked about ticket prices, MacKinnon did not give a direct answer.
Many travellers already find existing rail services costly, and some worry that high-speed rail could face similar concerns.
MacKinnon explained that the government has not yet selected an operator for the rail service. Officials will open the process to bids, allowing companies to compete to run the system.
Debate Likely to Continue
The proposed rail line continues to spark discussion across the country. Supporters see it as a modern transportation solution, while critics question its cost and planning.
As the government moves forward, Canadians will watch closely to see how the project develops and whether it meets expectations.
