Lyle attended the hearing virtually, which lasted over 10 hours. BBC
Lyle Menendez has been denied parole, a day after his brother Erik was similarly blocked. Both brothers were convicted in the 1989 killings of their parents, Jose and Kitty Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home. The parole board cited concerns that Lyle still poses a risk to the public.
Parole Board Findings
The panel, different from the one reviewing Erik, highlighted Lyle’s lack of self-control and poor decision-making. Commissioner Julie Garland said, “We find your remorse is genuine… but you still struggle with anti-social personality traits like deception, minimization and rule breaking that lie beneath that positive surface.”
The board also referenced the brutal nature of the murders and Lyle’s history of lying about the events. He initially told police he believed the killings were a mob hit and created elaborate cover-up stories.
Lyle’s Apology
During the hearing, Lyle expressed deep remorse. “I'm profoundly sorry for who I was … for the harm that everyone has endured. I will never be able to make up for the harm and grief I caused everyone in my family. I am so sorry to everyone, and I will be forever sorry,” he said.
Prison Conduct and Concerns
The board raised concerns about Lyle’s long-term use of an illicit cell phone in prison. Commissioner Patrick Reardon questioned whether his positive activities—such as mentoring inmates and creating programs—should outweigh repeated rule violations. Lyle pleaded guilty to a cell phone violation as recently as March.
Despite the violations, Lyle told the panel he acted as a “peacekeeper” in prison and helped vulnerable inmates. He has earned a degree and is working toward a master’s while mentoring others and assisting survivors of abuse.
Risk Assessment
A risk evaluation before the hearing labeled Lyle a “moderate risk” if released, citing traits of deception, manipulation, and entitlement. The board emphasized that people who break rules in prison are more likely to break rules outside.
What’s Next?
Lyle can seek parole again in three years, with the possibility of a shorter wait of 18 months for good behaviour. The brothers have also requested clemency from California Governor Gavin Newsom, which could reduce their sentences or grant a pardon. The governor is also considering a request for a new trial based on alleged childhood abuse by their father, but the Los Angeles district attorney opposes it.
Supporters, including family members, spoke on Lyle’s behalf. His cousin Eileen Cano said, “While most people surrender to the crushing weight of prison life, Lyle rose above it. Lyle will not be a risk to the community because we as a family will hold him accountable.”
Prosecutor Ethan Milius argued against parole, stating Lyle has not genuinely accepted responsibility and continues to struggle with following rules. The parole board ultimately sided with the prosecutors, prioritizing public safety over his prison achievements.
